Kansas City Chiefs tight end Travis Kelce and pop superstar Taylor Swift have been dating for over a year, and as their relationship continues to flourish, special occasions like birthdays have taken on extra significance. Taylor celebrated her 35th birthday on December 13, but details about how Travis marked the occasion remained under wraps—until now.

Thanks to Gracie Hunt, daughter of Chiefs owner Clark Hunt, we now know how Travis showed his affection. In an exclusive conversation with PEOPLE, Gracie revealed that Travis enlisted the help of local baker Cami Sanromani, owner of Cami’s Cake Co., to create a special birthday cake for Taylor.

The cake was a delicious blend of chocolate and vanilla bean, and even had a unique design—it was a replica of Arrowhead Stadium, where the Chiefs play.

“Cami’s Cake Co. made this amazing cake of Arrowhead Stadium for the Signature Suite Lounge,” Gracie shared. “You might recognize her name because Travis also had her make the cake for Taylor’s birthday.” The heart-shaped cake, beautifully decorated with white icing and intricate details, was a personal and thoughtful gesture from Travis to Taylor on her special day.

This sweet surprise comes at a time when rumors surrounding the couple’s future have intensified. Fans have speculated about the possibility of an engagement after Taylor was spotted wearing an “infinity ring,” which some believe symbolizes a long-term commitment, possibly pointing toward marriage. While there’s no official confirmation yet, the couple’s bond seems stronger than ever, and their connection is evident.

As the Chiefs focus on their quest for a third consecutive Super Bowl, Travis is fully dedicated to his team’s success. However, once the season concludes, who knows what might be next for the couple? For now, though, Kelce is definitely winning Taylor’s heart with sweet and thoughtful gestures, like that heart-shaped birthday cake, making their relationship even more endearing.