Matchmaking the top 10 MLB free agents with the team where they fit best

With free agency well underway, teams have already told player agents if they are interested in their clients. The 30 teams across the league have done their homework, understand the market and are preparing contract proposals or have already submitted them. Agents are informing players about the teams that are in on them and how respective clubs view the players they’re pursuing — the pecking order.

image

AdvertisementJuan Soto is the clear headliner of this free-agent class, but the top of the market is also loaded with starting pitching (Corbin Burnes, Roki Sasaki and Max Fried to name a few) and legitimate power (Pete Alonso, Anthony Santander and more). None of us know where any of the top free agents will sign. Players consider a team’s chances of winning (short term and long term), geography, teammates, continuity, stability and — yes — money, among many factors, in picking their future team.

As we wait for the first big dominoes to fall, I selected my favorite matches for each of the top 10 free agents, pairing them with the team where they fit best. Keep in mind that all of these star players fit well with multiple teams. These are not my predictions for where these free agents will sign, nor am I using inside intel or reading the tea leaves on where they’re headed.

This is simply a fun exercise to discuss the top of the market and what I think the best fits are for both the players and teams. If you think there are better matches, let me know in the comments section. (Players’ ages are as of Nov.

19. All statistics are from the 2024 season unless otherwise noted. WAR and OPS+ are according to Baseball Reference.

) 1. Juan Soto, RFAge: 26WAR: 7. 9 OPS+: 178Favorite match: YankeesThe Soto sweepstakes has all the offseason drama we dream about.

The New York rivalry between the Yankees and Mets, the AL East rivalry between the Yankees and Red Sox, the East Coast-West-Coast rivalry between the Dodgers and big-market teams on the other side of the country. To me, Soto’s three best landing spots are the Yankees, Mets and Dodgers, in that order. I love that the Red Sox are back playing with the big teams in free agency and that the Blue Jays are pursuing Soto, like they did with Shohei Ohtani a year ago.

I just don’t think Boston and Toronto will be able to land him. I could still see the Phillies and maybe the Giants in the mix as well. But my favorite fit for Soto is with the Yankees as long as owner Hal Steinbrenner is willing to make the biggest offer — or match it — because that’s likely what it’s going to take.

AdvertisementWatching Soto and Aaron Judge was like watching Ruth and Gehrig or Mantle and Maris, and I just want that dynamic duo to continue. Yankees fans loved Soto and he loved them back; I don’t see any reason for a divorce. 2.

Corbin Burnes, RHPAge: 30WAR: 3. 4 ERA: 2. 92Favorite match: MetsMets president of baseball operations David Stearns understands the importance of having an ace as they look to build on last season’s success and pursue a World Series championship.

He will always emphasize pitching and defense over everything else and his relationship with Burnes dates back to their Brewers days. Owner Steve Cohen is not afraid to outbid the marketplace and I just can’t imagine the Mets getting outbid for Burnes. It’s a perfect fit for both the player and club.

3. Roki Sasaki, RHPAge: 23ERA: 2. 35 over 111 innings in NPBFavorite match: Red SoxSasaki fits with all 30 teams, but there will be no bidding war in terms of money.

Because of his age, he will be considered an international amateur free agent, so Sasaki will receive only international bonus pool money from whatever club is fortunate enough to sign him. He’s going to prioritize stability, lifestyle and a team’s track record with player development in making his decision. Another factor: Endorsement potential.

He’ll have to wait three years for salary arbitration and six years for free agency, so in the meantime, endorsement deals with Japanese companies will be key to maximizing his income if he wants to be paid like the future star that he is. The Red Sox have a promising pitching program under Andrew Bailey and their leadership team of manager Alex Cora and chief baseball officer Craig Breslow, along with minority owner Theo Epstein working behind the scenes, could provide a solid foundation for Sasaki. He could maximize endorsements in the large market of Boston and become the face of their pitching staff for years to come.

Regardless of where he signs, he has the potential to become a full-fledged ace and Cy Young Award candidate. GO DEEPERWhy Roki Sasaki, the top prospect with ace upside, isn’t necessarily destined for Dodgers4. Max Fried, LHPAge: 30WAR: 3.

5 ERA: 3. 25Favorite match: OriolesAlthough the Orioles are fighting to retain Burnes, he is expected to depart in free agency, so they’ll likely need a top-of-the-rotation starter to replace him. Fried would fit nicely.

He’s as consistent as they come and one of the best lefty ground-ball pitchers in the league. The Orioles’ decision to move in their left-field wall shouldn’t hurt Fried’s effectiveness much due to his ground-ball rate (58. 2 percent in 2024) .

Their plethora of infielders bodes well for the defense behind him. Fried’s postseason experience and ability to perform in the biggest moments are qualities the Orioles need. Though I also like his fit back with the Braves or with teams such as the Mets and Giants, I just think the Orioles need him more than the other teams.

Advertisement5. Pete Alonso, 1BAge: 29WAR: 2. 6 OPS+: 123Favorite match: MarinersHow can the Mariners build the best starting rotation in baseball, then not add the offense it takes to get to the postseason and have a chance to win a World Series?

I just don’t get it. Alonso would be a huge addition to their lineup behind Julio Rodríguez, making it more difficult to pitch to J-Rod. That pair of big bats would have a chance at 70 homers between them.

Alonso’s personality and team first-approach could also help improve the Mariners’ culture. That said, re-signing with the Mets is probably the second-best landing spot for Polar Bear Pete if they don’t land Soto. 6.

Alex Bregman, 3BAge: 30WAR: 4. 1 OPS+: 118Favorite match: AstrosI can’t imagine Bregman in any other uniform. He’s been one of the faces of the Astros franchise since they drafted him with the second overall pick in 2015.

As much as I could see Bregman signing with the Red Sox, Mets or Yankees, he’s one of those players like Tony Gwynn, George Brett and Barry Larkin who I just can’t envision playing for another city. He and Jose Altuve deserve to retire as Astros. We’ll see if Houston does what it takes to keep Bregman, but for this exercise, I’m not putting him anywhere else.

GO DEEPERAstros owner: Bregman talks ongoing, team exploring backup plans7. Blake Snell, LHPAge: 31WAR: 2. 1 ERA: 3.

12Favorite match: Blue JaysThe Blue Jays could struggle to attract players to Toronto given the state of their farm system and their current offensive depth. However, they might be willing to overpay, in both years and dollars, to add a Cy Young Award talent, despite Snell’s risk of injuries, lack of innings and lack of year-to-year consistency. The Blue Jays can’t be picky in upgrading their offense and pitching if they want to contend in 2025.

It’s also important for Toronto to improve the team this offseason to help convince Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette to sign long-term contracts. 8.

Anthony Santander, RFAge: 30WAR: 2. 9 OPS+: 134AdvertisementFavorite match: NationalsThe Orioles are pushing to re-sign Santander, but he’d be a great pickup for several contenders — including the Mariners, Astros, Cubs, Guardians and Tigers — that are looking for offense. However, my favorite match for Tony Taters would take him down Interstate 95 from Baltimore to Washington D.

C. The last time the Nationals were building a world championship club, they overpaid for free-agent outfielder Jayson Werth, signing him to a seven-year, $126 million deal in the 2010-11 offseason. The industry ripped the Nationals for that contract at the time, but it marked the beginning of their run to a World Series title in 2019.

Could history repeat itself? The Nationals aren’t getting Santander unless they overpay like they did back then. They want middle-of-the-order impact and adding Santander’s 40-home run bat to their lineup of developing hitters would provide a big boost.

9. Willy Adames, SSAge: 29WAR: 3. 1 OPS+: 118Favorite match: DodgersTeams are lining up for Adames, who is willing to sign as a shortstop, second baseman or third baseman if it gets him the most years and dollars and lands with a club that’s a perennial contender.

I love the fit with the Dodgers, especially with the idea of Betts, who is moving back to the infield, at second base. Beyond upgrading the Dodgers at shortstop, Adames would bring more of the positive energy and enthusiasm that are calling cards of their clubhouse. His personality is a perfect fit for a Dave Roberts team.

10. Christian Walker, 1BAge: 33WAR: 2. 6 OPS+: 121Favorite match: YankeesSeveral teams need a first baseman, including the Mariners, Diamondbacks and even the Mets if they don’t bring back Alonso.

However, I think the Yankees are the ideal fit for Walker. He’s a Gold Glove first baseman who would extend their lineup with his power. (He has averaged more than 30 homers per season over the past three years.

) He would be a huge upgrade over Anthony Rizzo, who is not expected back with the Yankees in 2025. GO DEEPERFifteen notable MLB players who could be traded this offseasonGO DEEPERAll-MLB team 2024: Ohtani, Soto only repeat winners as Bowden picks the best at each positionGO DEEPERMLB front office check-in: Key offseason needs and goals for all 30 teams(Top image: Juan Soto: Luke Hales / Getty Images; Max Fried: Julio Aguilar / Getty Images)This post was originally published on this site be sure to check out more of their content.

Related Posts

Former Major League Executive Details Toronto Blue Jays Sales Pitch to Juan Soto

Last week, the Toronto Blue Jays met with superstar outfielder Juan Soto. They were the first of four (known) scheduled meetings with the free agent, who could…

Astros, Blue Jays, Braves, Red Sox Among Teams Interested In Willy Adames

Willy Adames is drawing “very broad” interest in free agency, with MLB Network’s Jon Morosi (X link) naming the Astros, Blue Jays, Braves, and Red Sox as…

Houston Astros ballpark to be renamed Daikan Park from Minute Maid starting Jan. 1, 2025

HOUSTON, Texas (KTRK) — Minute Maid Park, home of the Houston Astros, as we know it is no more. Well, at least the name. The Astros announced…

Rays’ 2028 Stadium Deal In Jeopardy

The Rays will play their 2025 home games at Tampa’s George M. Steinbrenner Field — the Yankees’ spring training home — in the wake of damage wreaked…

Five things to watch on the Baseball Hall of Fame ballot: How can Ichiro not be unanimous?

Woohoo. It’s that time again. Hall of Fame election time. Baseball’s 2025 Hall ballot was announced Monday — featuring one guy destined for an all-time landslide (Ichiro…

Cincinnati Reds pitching plans more clear with Nick Martinez’ decision to accept $21M QO

The Cincinnati Reds‘ offseason workload just got a lot more manageable with the decision by their top pitcher to return in 2025. Swingman Nick Martinez, who produced…

Leave a Reply